My 99-Year-Old Mother’s Return to Her Childhood Farmhouse

My mother grew up devouring classics like Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farm, the Elsie Dinsmore series, and Pollyanna.

Those late-19th- and early-20th-century novels always delivered happy endings and rock-solid morals. Some of the most uplifting tales centered on lost or estranged family members finally reuniting.

Recently my 99-year-old mother reached across more than six decades to touch her own childhood memories—and Stuart and I watched it happen.

A Spark on President Avenue
The search began several weeks ago while we drove Mother to our daughter’s new home in Lancaster. As we headed south on President Avenue, she suddenly exclaimed, “This is how we drove to Grandma Herr’s house!”

I have rarely traveled that stretch of road, and I couldn’t recall ever seeing a place the family called “Grandma Herr’s.” Determined to find it, we steered toward the WGAL television studio building to scout for anything resembling an old farmhouse. (We knew the Herr family had once sold their farm to the corporation behind WGAL.)

We spotted a promising house that looked like it might have a farm history, looked it up on Zillow, and jotted down the address. I mailed a note to “the owner” at the address, asking if Henry and Mary Herr had built the house. Within days, the current owner called. We had found the right place—and he invited us over.

Stepping Back in Time

Sunday dawned crisp and radiant. After picking Mother up at her retirement community and enjoying lunch at Marmalade Restaurant, we pulled into the driveway.

There it was, etched into the side of the brick wall:

The original date stone on the side of “Grandma Herr’s house.”

Inside, the owner walked us through how he had both preserved and thoughtfully rebuilt the home over the decades. For Mother, it was a whirlwind. She could only recognize out buildings, staircase, and original door fixtures.

Trying to absorb all the changes.

Look at her face as she traces the story of the house’s transformation in the photo album.

Ringing the Dinner Bell

In the five and a half years since Stuart and I moved to Lititz, we have shared countless Sunday outings with Mother. Yet this one, as she would say, “takes the cake.”

Before we left, Mother stepped outside and rang the old farm dinner bell—calling the boys in (she had four brothers, all deceased now) just like she did in the olden days.

Here’s how we celebrated the end of a wonderful visit:

Not only did we find a house hidden in plain sight, but we also turned our attention to the woman who was queen of that house, at least in the eyes of her namesake and granddaughter.

Grandma Barbara Herr

This adventure brought to life a woman who died at the age of 79 (the age I’ll be on my next birthday). Grandma Herr doted on Mother—her only daughter’s only daughter—until she passed away in 1942, when Mother was just 14.

Until very recently, that house stood hidden in plain sight. Now, we haven’t just uncovered an old family landmark; we have brought Grandma Herr’s memory back to life.

Here she is, standing on the left. After her daughter Anna Mary (on the right) married my grandfather, John G. Hess, Grandma Herr lived in this farmhouse with her bachelor son, Chris.

 

Stories That Came Back After the Visit

Stepping back inside the house didn’t just reconnect Mother to a building—it unlocked a flood of Grandma Herr memories. Since our visit, I have started cataloging the stories she has recalled.

Conquering the Dark Hallway

One memory ties directly to the layout of the house itself. Inside the front door, a staircase climbed to a long hallway leading to the bedrooms. When Mother was around four years old (about the time her brother Allen was born), she spent her first night away from home there.
Tucked into a big, unfamiliar bed at the end of that dark corridor, with black night pressing against the windows, young Barbara Ann felt terrified. She recalled a Sunday school lesson about letting go of fear, whispered a prayer, and let her childhood faith steady her until she drifted off to sleep.
The steps inside the front door led to the bedrooms in a long hallway that frightened young Barbara Ann.

The steps inside the front door led to the bedrooms in a long hallway that frightened young Barbara Ann.

A Dime Too Steep, and an Ice Cream Float

Grandma Herr was a widow. She and her son farmed enough acres to cover their expenses, though cash remained tight—and frugality ran deep in the family veins. While Grandma lavished her only granddaughter with food, smiles, and undivided attention, her practical streak occasionally disappointed the little girl.

One afternoon, Grandma invited Barbara Ann to ride the trolley into downtown Lancaster. Even though the ride covered less than two miles, the journey thrilled her. Downtown bustled with energy. Inside one of the big department stores, Barbara Ann spotted a toy broom in the children’s section and pleaded with her big hazel eyes.

Grandma hated to refuse, yet she held firm: “Ten cents is too high a price. Let’s keep going.” Instead, she steered Barbara Ann toward the store’s soda fountain and ordered an ice cream float—which instantly became the most delectable treat of the little girl’s young life.

The Little Green Rocking Chair

When Mother turned twelve, she noticed two new treasures sitting in Grandma’s house: a doll and a small, green rocking chair. Mother secretly hoped for the doll, yet Grandma must have decided she was ready for a more grown-up gift. She gave her the rocking chair.

Mother has carried that little green chair through every move and downsizing of her life. Today, at 99, she still sits on it every morning to pull on her support hose. Someday, perhaps, it will pass into the hands of another granddaughter.

The gift from Grandma Herr, in 1940, two years before she died.

The gift from Grandma Herr, in 1940, two years before she died.

One Sunday drive didn’t just uncover a transformed old farmhouse—it proved that the places we love never truly leave us, and neither do the people who shaped who we are.

Do you have a connection to the homes of your grandparents? What memories do you recall from either the places or the grandparents of your childhood?

 

Shirley Showalter

11 Comments

  1. Melodie M. Davis on November 16, 2026 at 3:46 pm

    Love this and all the memories it conjures up for your family. Amazing!

    It also reminds me of what happened to our old house. Just recently, the Amish family living there, knocked down our whole house near Middlebury, Ind., I can’t blame the Amish family wanting a much newer house with large rooms etc. for their family. I’ve been in at least one Amish home which was quite large, with room children etc. They moved it far back from CR 22, (from MIddlebury to Gosehn) which may have been their plan, to keep children and grandchildren away from the road.

    It made us quite sad that it was knocked away, which I plan to write about shortly. That’s life, we know. But it was a home we savored for many years as children and later introduced our own grandchildren to. Memories, good and not so good.

    • Shirley Showalter on November 16, 2026 at 4:18 pm

      Thanks, Melodie. You have a story almost opposite of this one–a more painful one, even as you are resigned to the inevitability of change. I imagine you might be doing some collecting of photos and stories to keep the memories alive?

      Sometimes it also helps to get to know the new owners and see them enjoying their own ideas of how family and space go together.

  2. Merril D Smith on November 16, 2026 at 4:01 pm

    It’s so wonderful that your mom at 99 is in such great shape! It’s lovely that all of you were able to see her grandmother’s home and connect. I don’t think my grandparents on either side ever owned a home. They lived in various apartments around Philadelphia, after they had immigrated here. Both of my grandmothers died when I was very young, but I remember both of my grandfathers very well. Both of them lived into their 90s, as did my mom.

    • Shirley Showalter on November 16, 2026 at 4:25 pm

      I think I remember seeing pictures of your mom enjoying life well into her 90s, Merril. Have you written about the immigrant experience in Philadelphia? My immigrant ancestor arrived in 1717 and headed straight to the country, The only city dwellers in my family, that I know of, emerged in my generation. All of them were looking for as much familiarity as possible, I imagine, and all of them searched for opportunity in the new land. We are the heirs of their striving and desire.

  3. Lynn on November 16, 2026 at 4:02 pm

    I love this story…….. all that unfolds within it There is richness in every part- from the memory triggered while on the drive to the beautiful chair and all it symbolizes. (-: So grateful this story found its way to your family!

    • Shirley Showalter on November 16, 2026 at 4:34 pm

      We are grateful too, Lynn. For the places made sacred by memory and for the stewardship of the property by a family who never knew ours. Thanks for letting me know you read and enjoyed.

  4. Maren C. Tirabassi on November 16, 2026 at 4:03 pm

    Colleges connect. My paternal grandparents (only two generations down from the Hessian soldier who was earliest here) were living in Prairie HIll ,Missouri with their daughter and four boys. A black man was lynched in town and they decided to pack and move north the next day to Iowa City, Iowa and my grandfather took a job as the janitor of the University of Iowa Memorial Union so that his children could use his benefit and the boys football prowess to get a college degree. My maternal grandmother was college educated … her mother had come from Norway to be indentured to the banker in Northfield, Minnesota for seven years and she started at Carleton College but after two years St. Olaf College opened and they taught in Norwegian so she transferred. Their daughter, my grandmother, was dressed in most of her clothes and carried everything else in a satchel and was sent by train from Minnesota to Wellesley for college. She returned married and had children in Minnesota but her husband died young. She moved south to Ames, Iowa and became a housemother at Iowa State University. My mother went to the University of Iowa.. I later went to and finished at Carleton College. Colleges!

    • Shirley Showalter on November 16, 2026 at 4:43 pm

      This is an amazing story, Maren. What a great tradition of high-quality education! No wonder you have such a way with words. And maybe languages, too? Have you told the story of your ancestor who moved because of the lynching? Do you have any explanation of why he chose this response?

      People like you with generations of education in their family histories made my jaw drop as a first-generation college student after ten generations of farmers. 🙂

  5. Marian Beaman on November 16, 2026 at 4:34 pm

    This post has all the ingredients of posts I love: memory, time with loved ones, and a bit of intrigue.

    We sold both homes of Mother and Grandma Longenecker. But some artifacts remain in our home: the large oak table in my dining room with 3 leaves and an ancient chair from Great Grandpa Sam Martin.

    I’m happy I still have the rocking chair I “read” books on in early childhood and my Mother’s rocking chair from her own Metzler childhood. I wrote about the Hans Longenecker House which featured a photo of my mother sitting on her high chair on the farmhouse porch: https://marianbeaman.com/2021/08/11/housing-highs-hans-longenecker-house/

    How very fortunate you are to have a mother who’s almost a centenarian. I know you cherish the moments with her and share her glee. at discoveries.

    • Shirley Showalter on November 16, 2026 at 5:12 pm

      Thanks, Marian, for sending me to a post of yours I missed during our transition from VA to PA. I’m glad you were able to preserve a few heirlooms, including a rocking chair.

      And yes, I do cherish the glee. That’s a great word for Mother’s high spirits when she can use what is left of sight and sound and memory. For example, this last Sunday we watched the movie “A Walk in the Woods” about Bill Bryson’s attempt to walk the Appalachian Trail, including his encounters with bears and slide down rocks. Mother said as she was getting up, “I guess farming tobacco wasn’t that hard after all.”

  6. Elaine Hostetler on November 16, 2026 at 6:05 pm

    Thanks, Shirley, for this wonderful story of your mother and her stories. Barbara Ann is a remarkable woman.

Leave a Comment