If you subscribe to Christian Century magazine, you may have read my review of City of Tranquil Light in the fall books edition. If you aren’t a subscriber, you can read it below. Dora Dueck also wrote an excellent review on her blog, Borrowing Bones. I encourage you to check it out.

Caldwell, Bo. City of Tranquil Light. New York: Henry Holt and Company, 2010.

If Barbara Kingsolver’s masterpiece The Poisonwood Bible, has formed your image of Christian missionaries in the twentieth century, you need an equal and opposite set of characters to round out (not replace) your historical, theological, and literary imagination. Bo Caldwell’s Will and Katherine Kiehn are not as dramatic as Kingsolver’s Nathan and Orleanna Price, but their quiet faith, love of their adopted country, and devotion to each other will stir all but the most callous readers. If you are immune to quietness as a form of passion and simplicity as beauty, beware. Otherwise, you are in for a treat. This is a great book.

The narrator of this tale, Will Kiehn, is an unlikely hero—clumsy, slow, sometimes lazy—by his own confession. A Mennonite farm boy from Oklahoma, he is so humble that he thinks his biggest sin is pride. Having heard a clear call to go to China, he leaves his home and family and joins a company of other missionaries, including Katherine Friesen, the 22 year-old deaconess he will later marry.

The book opens in the 1960’s with an elderly Kiehn in a California retirement community, reflecting over his past, remembering a place—Kuang P’ing Ch’eng—City of Tranquil Light. A widower, he cherishes his Chinese bible, his German bible (the language of his parents), and his wife’s journal chronicling their 27 years as missionaries. An encounter with a Chinese-American Fuller brush man who recognizes him as “mu shih”—“shepherd-teacher” who baptized him in China—sets the stage for the opening chapters describing his religious heritage and his Mennonite formation on the plains of Oklahoma.

The scene then shifts to the year 1906, when both Will and Katherine set sail for China. We follow them through their introductory culture shock, to their demure courtship, quiet marriage, and their post as the only westerners in Kuang P’ing Ch’eng. Will narrates in the past tense while excerpts from Katherine’s journal offers a contrasting immediacy of the same scene in real time. Her italicized words bring her to life as her own character, full of vivacious energy even though she suffers from headaches and low physical stamina. She nevertheless applies her medical skills to the amazement and gratitude of villagers. Will learns to preach. And slowly a church begins to form.

In the midst of early success comes the greatest blessing of all—a daughter named Lily. The plot of the novel pivots around the death of Lily and the fact that medical supplies that could have cured her dysentery were stolen by a bandit named Hsiao Lao who then continues to enter and exit their lives through wars, famines, floods, and other near-death experiences. The book concludes after Katherine’s death, when Will’s mind returns to the remembered deepest places in his soul. His room in the retirement home is on the west side—the one closest to China.

Faith is the most obvious theme of this book. Will and Katherine both learn the lesson early in their sojourn that China will not bend toward them. They need to listen and bend toward China, trusting God to be wiser than they are. They do so gracefully, usually, and with difficulty at other times. Their church grows, not from hellfire preaching but the same way Jesus grew his motley band of followers—through the telling of stories and ministry to human need. Menno Simons, for whom the Mennonite church was named, said these words:

True evangelical faith cannot lie dormant.
It clothes the naked.
It feeds the hungry.
It comforts the sorrowful.
It shelters the destitute.
It serves those that harm it.
It binds up that which is wounded.

Will and Katherine lived this kind of evangelism; they applied to missions the first rule of medicine: first, do no harm.

But this is not a theological tract or a short course in up-to-date missiology. Caldwell’s vision stretches beyond admiration for faithful simplicity and for storytelling about the adventures of ordinary people in extraordinary circumstances. She connects the lives of Will and Katherine with a life force that emanates from the land, with memory older than time, and with the great traditions in literature.

On nearly every page of this book lie traces of another great book. The simple conversion story when Will kneels beside the plow in his field contains echoes of St. Augustine, e.e.cummings,   Francis Thompson, St. Paul, and Gerard Manley Hopkins. When Will’s father, who might have been angry to see his son leave the farm, instead embraces him, saying “you have chosen the better part. How could I refuse you?” he is the archetypal good father, echoing the words of Jesus himself in Luke 10:42 “Mary has chosen the better part, which shall not be taken away from her.”

The two books that came to my mind most often when reading this one were Willa Cather’s Death Comes for the Archbishop and Marilynn Robinson’s Gilead. In addition to quiet mystical experience of their main characters, these novels all root their deepest spiritual lessons in the power of place. Will describes how this kind of love penetrates:

“Each morning when I begin my daily walk, I start out by heading west, toward China. At times my life there seems almost imagined; bandits and soldiers and magistrates, floods and droughts and famines and war, seem as distant as the moon. On other days it is the present that feels imagined and Kuang P’ing Ch’eng that seems more real than the poached egg and toast I eat for breakfast. Certain smells make China instantly real to me: anything cooked with garlic, freshly cut wood, antiseptic, the crispness of the air on the first autumn day. These scents stop me in my tracks.”

As he kneels by his bed at night, in a scene reminiscent of  his conversion years ago in an Oklahoma field, he gives thanks for his parents and for Katherine and Lily, working his way from the names of his Chinese friends to the City of Tranquil Light itself and then to the country where he can no longer go. As his heart settles on China, he feels a familiar homesickness, a gift that tells him this earth is not his home.

Joseph Conrad and Barbara Kingsolver took us to the heart of darkness. Bo Caldwell arouses the hope, even the conviction, that beyond darkness of all kinds lies a heavenly city—a city of tranquil light.

Shirley Showalter


  1. Saloma Furlong on October 16, 2010 at 1:05 am

    If the book is as beautifully written as your review, I will love this book. I feel as if I am on the end of life journey with the protagonist. I only hope I will face that time in my life with as much grace as what you’ve described here.

    Thank you very much for reviewing it for us.

    • shirleyhs on October 16, 2010 at 8:41 pm

      Thanks, Saloma. Like you, I am looking for good role models for the next stages of life, and Will seems like a good one. I also enjoyed the Dalai Lama’s book On Dying. He offers practices that we can do before old age that will make the day of our death seem much more like all those other days of meditation.

      Come back and tell me what you think after you read this book. It is technically a novel, but, like The Help and Freedom, reviewed on this blog by Lanie Tankard, it contains an internal memoir. In this case, the author used actual missionary journals also.

  2. Brenda Bartella Peterson on October 16, 2010 at 3:30 pm

    What an inspiring review. I look forward to reading the book! I would also encourage those who have enjoyed this book and The Poisonwood Bible to try Gods of Noonday by Elaine Orr. It is Elaine’s memoir of growning up as the child of Baptist missionaries in Africa. A wonderful read about Elaine’s experience of loving the country of her birth.

    • shirleyhs on October 18, 2010 at 12:36 am

      Hi, Brenda. Welcome to 100memoirs. I took a few minutes to check out your site also. Looks very interesting. Thanks for the recommendation. Sounds like a book readers here might enjoy.

  3. DazyDayWriter on October 17, 2010 at 3:08 pm

    Well said: “Joseph Conrad and Barbara Kingsolver took us to the heart of darkness. Bo Caldwell arouses the hope, even the conviction, that beyond darkness of all kinds lies a heavenly city—a city of tranquil light.”

    Sounds like an excellent book. Thanks for the insightful review, Shirley, and for making me curious enough to want to read it … all at the same time.

    Also writing about light in SunnyRoomStudio via “Peace at Dawn.” Always seek the light right … ?! Best to you, Daisy

    • shirleyhs on October 18, 2010 at 1:05 am

      Daisy, you really are amazing. I couldn’t believe you have only been blogging since February! You build community very intentionally. We could all learn from you. Now to comment on your post.

  4. Kathleen on October 17, 2010 at 11:38 pm

    I too look forward to reading this book about the places our hearts are forever drawn toward though we live in the reality of now. Thank you for a reflective review.

    • shirleyhs on October 18, 2010 at 1:08 am

      Kathleen, I love finding your tracks here. Thanks. And I was honored to have you link to one of my past posts on your on site. Keep building perfect days–and keep coming back!

  5. Johanna on October 18, 2010 at 3:27 am

    A wonderful, sensitive and intuitive review that resonates in my heart and my spirit! From what you have written, I think you would also enjoy my new spiritual memoir, Graffiti On My Soul (by Johanna), which is a powerful journey of faith and forgiveness. I would love (and be very grateful) to have you review it for me ! My life is unusual; eight years after entering a monastery at the age of seventeen I was to leave, and to marry, and my life became embroiled in a time of horror . A reader said, “Your story reads like an Agatha Christie novel, but the words are so beautiful they sound like music”. As an authentic personal journey it is lyrical, funny, raw and mystical. You can find further information at http://www.eloquentbooks.com/GraffitiOnMySoul.html

    • shirleyhs on October 20, 2010 at 10:00 pm

      Johanna, I have a moratorium on accepting new books to review right now. I have promised to review two in the months of October and November and can’t do more than that, I’m sorry to say. But thank you for your own kind words here. I do hope you’ll come back.

  6. Renee Quistorf on November 17, 2010 at 6:10 pm

    Read it, thanks to this blog. Fast read, enjoyed it. Went to China with GC SST in 1983. Amazing “how much I know that I don’t know,” as Will says in the book. Thanks.

    • shirleyhs on May 15, 2013 at 4:20 pm

      Renee, I somehow missed your comment here long ago. But it delighted me today. Hope you find this response — after two years! Thanks for stopping by. I appreciate the connection we made in other places.

  7. Kenneth Hursh on May 15, 2013 at 4:04 pm

    Nice review, Shirley. I just did City on audiobook and also thought it was great. I loved how Caldwell expressed everything in the simplest words possible. It fit the characters so well. Listening to it was almost a meditative experience in addition to being an inspiring story.

  8. shirleyhs on May 15, 2013 at 4:22 pm

    Thanks, Kenneth. I can believe that listening was meditative. The voices made a deep impression on me, even though I was only reading them.

Leave a Comment